Stay at Hideaway Bay Resort, a 4.8-star resort hotel in Silver Creek, NY. Close to Evangola State Park and Dunkirk Lighthouse. Near Buffalo Niagara Intl Airport.
Visitors consistently highlight the attentive staff, tranquil setting, and cozy accommodations, making it a favored choice for relaxing getaways near Evangola State Park and other local attractions.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Hideaway Bay Resort is a resort hotel located at 42 Lake Ave in Silver Creek, NY, offering a tranquil setting on the shores of the lake. Its small cottages provide a cozy, home-like atmosphere, with well-maintained and beautifully decorated accommodations praised for cleanliness and comfort. The resort features lake views, a beach area, a hot tub, a wood-heated sauna, and outdoor fire pits, making it suited for relaxation and casual social gatherings.
Guests frequently highlight the attentive and friendly staff as a standout aspect of their stay, contributing to a welcoming and accommodating environment. The onsite restaurant is noted for good service, picturesque lakefront dining, and enjoyable food, complemented by amenities like a charcuterie board and simple but fresh continental breakfasts. However, some mention that certain structural features, like stairs to upper floors, may be less accessible.
Its location offers easy access to local attractions such as Evangola State Park, known for its swimming beaches and outdoor activities, the historic Dunkirk Lighthouse with maritime exhibits, and nearby wineries like Merritt Estate. The resort is within reasonable driving distance from Buffalo Niagara International Airport and other regional airports, making it accessible for travelers.
Ideal for guests seeking a peaceful getaway with opportunities for sightseeing and recreation, Hideaway Bay Resort suits small groups, couples, and leisure travelers who appreciate scenic surroundings and a relaxed pace. While the property scores well overall with a 4.8 rating from nearly 200 reviews, the area’s train activity has been noted but generally does not detract from the experience.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with warm smiles and exceptional service. The staff are genuinely friendly and go out of their way to make you feel welcome. We absolutely loved our stay! Gorgeous lake views, delicious food at the onsite restaurant and relaxing environment. The rooms were beautiful, the beds super comfy, and everything felt spotless and welcoming. If you’re looking for a relaxing getaway with breathtaking views, top-notch hospitality, and amazing food, this is the place. We can’t wait to come back!
We had a lovely getaway. The beach is so serene. Great water access. The team is super happy to help. The restuarant is a great experience - beautiful location, good service, and good food.
Had the most amazing time celebrating a bachelorette weekend! The owners and staff went above and beyond to make our stay unforgettable—so kind, accommodating, and welcoming. The cottages were beautifully decorated with the cutest touches, and the views were absolutely breathtaking. One note: the staircase to the second floor is a bit narrow and could be tricky for anyone with mobility issues or those who are a little clumsy (we had a few laughs!). The continental breakfast was simple, fresh, and delicious—just what we needed to start the day. But the highlight was dinner: a private table set up right by the water, and it was absolutely stunning. They truly did everything in their power to make the trip special. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a peaceful, relaxing getaway!
Our girls getaway overnight at Hideaway Bay was AMAZING!! The management team and staff were all so kind and attentive… loved the cabin / bungalow setup, beautifully decorated, included everything you could possibly need!! Really enjoyed sitting on the balcony having drinks and snacks (loved their charcuterie board) with a great view of the lake … the hot tub and sauna were a big hit with us !! We thoroughly enjoyed our meal at the Drift , and then a bonfire afterwards!! Well done at thinking of everything… kudos to you, Christian & Kevin… u 2 are awesome hosts!! Thank you again and we will definitely be back on another visit to Hideaway Bay :)
Absolutely amazing weekend! I cannot say enough about it! It was perfect, from the serene ambiance, the amazing staff, mouthwatering food! Already booked our next stay!
Love this cottage. Hosts are fabulous. We love the setup of the cottage. We will definitely plan a trip to come back in the summer. We stayed this weekend for the Bills game. GO BILLS!!!
Perfect for a weekend or overnight. Tiny home-like houses to stay in. Great restaurant, really cool barrel sauna and hot tub that are heated with wood, bonfires on the beach. AMAZING! The 4 stars for the location is for the train that runs behind the resort. We did not find it to be a problem though.
Stayed here for a girls getaway. From the moment we arrived to check out, the entire staff was so nice and accommodating. I can't say enough about how nice they ALL were. We enjoyed time on the beach, in the hot tub, at the restaurant, the fire pit on the beach, sauna and breakfast! Beautiful cottages, very clean.
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
833 reviews 1 Lighthouse Pt Dr, Dunkirk, NY 14048, United States
1,689 reviews 10191 Old Lake Shore Rd, Irving, NY 14081, United States
210 reviews 2264 King Rd, Forestville, NY 14062, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at The Suites at Prairie Falls in Post Falls, ID. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, air conditioning, room service, and proximity to...
Stay at The Lodge Casino, a 4.2★ casino hotel in Black Hawk, CO offering slot machines, dining, free WiFi, parking, and easy acce...
Enjoy free breakfast, indoor pool, and gym at Holiday Inn Express & Suites Allen Park, MI. Close to Ford Motor Company and top mus...
Stay at Homewood Suites by Hilton ChattanoogaHamilton Place, an extendedstay hotel featuring suites with kitchens, free WiFi, p...
Contemporary Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites in Chicago River North offers free WiFi, hot breakfast, fitness center, and meeti...
Stay at Ocean Park Resort, a 4star motel near beaches and parks in Ocean Park, WA, featuring free WiFi, kidfriendly amenities, ...
Simple budget hotel in Sioux City, IA offering free breakfast, WiFi, parking, and a business center. Close to Sioux City Conventio...
Contemporary hotel in Vicksburg, MS offering indoor/outdoor pools, a bar & grill, free WiFi, LGBTQ+ friendly, near National Milit...
Comfortable roadside hotel with free WiFi and cable TV, rated 4.4 from 439 reviews. Close to Chinatown, Museum of Fine Arts, and ...
Stay at Hillcrest Motel Marshfield in WI with free breakfast, WiFi, and parking. Close to Wildwood Zoo, Marshfield Medical Center...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
